Former Michigan Prosecutor | Jonathan Andrew Paul
  • Crimes
    • Domestic Violence
    • Retail Fraud
    • Drug Offenses
    • Assaultive
    • College/Tailgate Offenses >
      • Minor in Possession
      • Ann Arbor MIP
      • Ann Arbor Fake ID
      • Ann Arbor UIP
      • Ann Arbor Open Container
    • Resisting Arrest
    • Handling a Traffic Ticket
    • Careless/Reckless Driving
    • Probation Violation
    • Early Discharge Probation
    • Larceny
    • Malicious Destruction of Property
    • Embezzlement
    • Juvenile Charges
  • Drunk Driving
    • Evidence >
      • Chemical Tests >
        • Implied Consent Law
        • Independent Chemical Test
        • Single Car Accident | DUI Defense
        • Effects of Body Temperature
        • Cross-Examining the DataMaster
        • Blood Testing 101
        • Impact of Methyl Alcohol/Paraldehyde
        • Radio Frequency Issues w/DataMaster
      • Right to Counsel
      • Preliminary Breath Test (PBT)
      • Field Sobriety Tests
      • Police Traffic Stop >
        • Sleeping in Car Defense
        • Cross-Examination - The Not Driving Defense
      • Police Statements
    • DUI Consequences >
      • Ignition Interlock
      • Restitution
      • Vehicle Immobilization
      • Travel Restrictions
      • Child Custody
      • Employment/Education
      • Traveling to Canada?
      • Vehicle Forfeiture
      • Civil Liability
      • Commercial Driver's License
    • DUI Trial Guide >
      • Jury Selection
      • Opening Statement
      • Cross-Examination
      • Closing Argument
      • Jury vs Bench Trial
    • Setting Bond >
      • Alcohol/Drug Testing Part #1
      • Alcohol/Drug Testing Part #2
      • Posting Bond
    • DUI Offenses >
      • Operating While Intoxicated
      • Operating While Visibly Impaired
      • Super Drunk/High BAC
      • Operating Presence of Controlled Substance
      • Child Endangerment
      • Felony Drunk Driving
      • DUI Under 21 Years Old
      • DUI Causing Injury/Death
    • Sobriety Court
    • DUI Pardons
  • Hiring a Super Lawyer
  • Courts
    • Wayne County >
      • More Courts >
        • Allen Park
        • Dearborn Heights
        • Detroit
        • Ecorse
        • Hamtramck
        • Harper Woods
        • Highland
        • Lincoln Park
        • Redford
        • Southgate
        • Taylor
        • Woodhaven
        • Wyandotte
      • Plymouth
      • Northville
      • Canton
      • Romulus
      • Livonia
      • Dearborn
      • Grosse Pointe
      • Westland
    • Oakland County >
      • Novi
      • Troy
      • Southfield
      • Royal Oak | Berkley
      • Rochester Hills
      • Farmington Hills
      • Bloomfield Hills
      • Waterford
      • Clarkston
      • Oak Park
      • Pontiac
      • Ferndale/Madison Heights/Hazel Park Drunk Driving DUI Criminal Attorney | Oakland County
    • Washtenaw County >
      • Ann Arbor
      • Chelsea
      • Pittsfield Township
      • Saline
      • Ypsilanti 14A
      • Ypsilanti 14B
    • Macomb County >
      • Center Line
      • Clinton Township
      • Eastpointe
      • Fraser
      • New Baltimore
      • Romeo
      • Roseville
      • Shelby Township
      • Sterling Heights
      • St. Clair Shores
      • Warren
    • Jackson County
    • Lenawee County
    • Livingston County
    • Monroe County
    • East Lansing
  • Expungement
    • DUI Expungement
  • 5-Star DUI Defense
  • Legal Guides
    • FAQ
    • DUI Expungement
    • Arrested in Michigan? NOW WHAT!
    • Being Investigated?
    • 18 Key Questions for DUI's
    • Michigan License Restoration
  • Client Reviews
  • Growth Mindset
  • Inside the Prosecutor Mind
    • Drunk Driving >
      • OWI First Offense
      • OWI Second Offense
      • OWI Third Offense
      • Field Sobriety Tests
      • Chemical Tests
      • Implied Consent
      • Hardship License
      • Sobriety Court
    • Expungement
    • Assault/DV Charges >
      • Domestic Violence
      • Misdemeanor Assault
      • Felonious Assault
    • Theft Offenses >
      • Retail Fraud
      • Embezzlement
      • Larceny
    • College Offenses >
      • Open Container
      • Minor in Possession (MIP)
      • Urinating in Public
      • Fake ID
    • Drug Charges >
      • Felony Drug Possession
    • Driving - Traffic >
      • Reckless Careless Driving
      • Driving While License Suspended
      • Leaving Scene of Accident
    • Disorderly Conduct
    • Probation Violation
    • Resisting Arrest
    • Malicious Destruction of Property
    • Travel Requests
    • Bond Violations
  • Contact Me
  • Leading with Empathy
  • Blog

Minor in Possession in Michigan, what the prosecutor really thinks about your case

5/16/2018

 
In 2018, a Minor in Possession charge is now a civil infraction. Prior to this year, this offense was a criminal misdemeanor. That seems like good news for my clients, and it sounded great to the lawmakers who created the law, but things are NOT playing out in a favorable way for people in Michigan. Yes, it is a win for someone not to have a criminal record for underage drinking, but there are a ton of collateral consequences, many of these issues, which I am fixing for people who screwed up their own case or received poor advice from other lawyers.

Prior to 2018, if you were charged with an MIP, you would likely plead guilty under a first offender program, do some probation, pay a fine, and your record is clear with no paper trail of the offense. Your case was non-public and you did not have to report it as a criminal conviction. Now, people are going into court, pleading responsible to the civil infraction of Minor in Possession, but this is a public record. Very public, just like a traffic ticket.

Sure it's not a criminal case, but it comes up and the facts/evidence are not any different. It's also a crime in most states, and I have had a client plead responsible to the civil infraction in Michigan, but his home state still suspended his license for 12 months, because that state still considered it a criminal offense. I've had clients get fired from a job because their employer had this on their record, and the employer didn't care if it was a crime or not, it just meant the same to them - breaking the law with alcohol.

This same logic would certainly apply to a grad school, employer, a scholarship committee etc. Let's evaluate someone who received an MIP in 2017 vs 2018.

In 2017, in a reasonable worse case scenario, the person would go on probation on the first offender program, excel, have the case dismissed, and the arrest/charge and plea would all be non-public. On applications there would be no need to put the offense, and there would be no record of it at the courthouse or on a public database. This person is safe from their past impacting their future plans.

In 2018, a Minor in Possession pops up in that same search, and most applications ask for any civil infractions in your past; that means you would need to list it and explain what happened. Now the person who sees that might say - "isn't an MIP a crime?" Or, it says civil infraction, but do I really want to hire or admit someone who "breaks the law?" - even one incident of underage drinking could send the wrong perception to the person reviewing the record.

They can easy then FOIA the police report connected to the MIP case, and there could be some embarrassing facts in there as a college kid charged with underage drinking. There could even be some facts about other crimes that are under first offender programs, or crimes not charged, but the facts could support them. Common other crimes that go with an MIP might be possessing a fake ID, urinating in public, disorderly conduct, disturbing the peace, public intoxication, open container etc.

As a former prosecutor, I understand the typical prosecutor mindset of "well he/she already caught a break" or "it's not even a crime". This can be frustrating to hear, and it's so shortsighted.

Most prosecutors DO NOT think outside the box and they don't understand or consider collateral consequences. That's like me saying well there's a gas leak at my house, and they say, well the house isn't on fire, what's the big deal? Sure, in the moment it's a civil infraction, but once that record becomes public it sets off fireworks in all directions for the client., and you can run from it, because it's not eligible for expungement This is why I have not allowed any of my clients charged with an MIP to walk into the courthouse and plead responsible.

I approach these cases as if the offense is still a serious criminal offense, and value the fact that my client should not be underage drinking, and we can learn from this. We over prepare and outwork the others charged wit hthe same offense.

​To simply ignore what happened will only lead to the client piling up MIP's and getting into more trouble with alcohol in the immediate future, and down the road as they get older. It's my goal to workout an alternative outcome with the prosecutor that is NOT an MIP.

This could be accomplished in many ways; we can turn the MIP into a different civil infraction, which won't pop up as an alcohol offense; this would be the optimal result, but not always offered by a prosecutor. That is why my client's go above and beyond with a proactive approach to push the limits on negotiations, and give me the currency I need to make things happen.

Comments are closed.
    top criminal lawyer michigan, metro detroit, northville, plymouth attorney
    Jonathan Andrew PaulReviewsout of 164 reviews

    Call Me Today
    248-924-9458
    ​
    Email Me

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    Search the Blog

    Blog Posts

    - The Michigan Retrograde Extrapolation Guide

    - Selecting an Ann Arbor Criminal Defense Lawyer

    - Selecting an Oakland County Criminal Defense Lawyer

    - Drunk Driving Consults

    - The One Question Your Michigan Criminal Defense Lawyer Should not be Able to Answer

    - Are the police allowed to follow me home from a bar?

    - Is it illegal to smoke weed and drive a car in Michigan? What's the legal limit for pot?

    - Michigan Police Confessions 101

    - Michigan 7411 Drug Crimes

    - FAQ: Shoplifting in Michigan

    - Michigan HYTA Eligibility

    - Can I be on probation while    away at college?

    - What is a Deferred Judgment of Guilt?

    - Michigan CDL Alcohol Penalties 

    - Ann Arbor Arrested for Fake ID, Urinating in Public, Minor in Possession, Open Container

    - Should I Admit to Drinking Alcohol?

    - Arrested for Minor in Possession in Ann Arbor?

    - Michigan DUI Probation Violation Hearings

    - How To: Claiming Self Defense at Trial 

    - Michigan Sex Offender FAQ

    - Should I use the Public Defender?

    - Washtenaw County Felony OWI Options

    - Handling a Michigan traffic ticket

    - How to beat a Careless Driving Charge

    - Hiring a Wayne County Criminal Defense Lawyer

    - Michigan DUI Concealed Weapon Permit

    - What's a Michigan Preliminary Examination?

    Neighbor Disputes

    - Can I Remove my GPS Tether?

    - Vehicle forfeitures 
     - Will I lose my license for a drug charge?

    - Michigan Driver's Responsibility Fees

    - Falsely Accused on Domestic Violence
    - 48th District Court Prosecutors 
    - Am I eligible for expungement with two convictions?
Representing clients in Ann Arbor, Canton, Brighton, Howell, Saline, Adrian, Taylor, Plymouth, Northville, Westland, Ypsilanti, Pittsfield Towsnhip, Warren, Sterling Heights, Farmington, Pontiac, Romulus, Lansing, Novi, South Lyon, Southfield, Birmingham, Bloomfield Hills, Royal Oak, Troy, Rochester, Jackson, East Lansing, Garden City, Livonia, Dearborn, Detroit, St Clair Shores, Hazel Park, Ferndale, Madison Heights, Waterford, Milford, Shelby Township Clarkston, Oak Park, Berkley, Fraser, Sterling Heights, Clinton Township and others throughout Washtenaw, Wayne, Monroe, Jackson,  Macomb, Ingham, Lenawee, Livingston, Oakland County & Northern Michigan 

Representing clients faced with DUI/drunk driving, retail fraud, possession of marijuana, domestic violence, reckless driving, leaving the scene of an accident, fake ID, open container  and other misdemeanor and felony charges. 

Evening & Weekend Service Available Call Me: 248-924-9458

Picture

Ann Arbor Office Location

Plymouth Office Location

Michigan Defense Attorney Jonathan Paul - Former New York & Michigan Prosecutor