What to Do If You’re Charged with Retail Fraud in Fenton, Michigan - 67th District Court in Genesee County - Shoplifting Attorney

​If you’ve been charged with retail fraud in Fenton, Michigan, you’re not alone. Retail fraud, often referred to as shoplifting, is one of the most common offenses among first-time offenders in Genesee County. For many, this charge comes as a complete shock, leading to feelings of embarrassment, anxiety, and uncertainty about what comes next. However, a single mistake doesn’t have to define your future. In this article, we’ll explore the basics of Michigan’s retail fraud laws, what to expect if your case goes before Judge McCabe, and how an experienced attorney can help you move forward without a criminal record.

Understanding Michigan’s Retail Fraud Laws

Retail fraud in Michigan is a broad term covering several actions, including:

• Taking merchandise from a store without paying.
• Altering price tags or labels to pay less.
• Attempting to return stolen items for cash or store credit.

For the prosecution to secure a conviction, they must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that:

• You took or moved items for sale.
• You intended to steal the merchandise permanently.
• The incident took place inside or immediately outside the store while it was open.

The Three Degrees of Retail Fraud in Michigan

Michigan categorizes retail fraud into three degrees based on the value of the stolen items:

• Third Degree: Items valued under $200. This is a misdemeanor punishable by up to 93 days in jail and fines.
• Second Degree: Items valued between $200 and $1,000. This is a one-year misdemeanor.
• First Degree: Items valued over $1,000. This is a felony, carrying the risk of significant fines and prison time.

Understanding the charge you’re facing is the first step toward building a strong defense.

Judge McCabe’s Courtroom in Fenton: Key Things to Know

If your case is being heard by Judge McCabe at the 67th District Court in Fenton, it’s important to understand his approach. Known for a fair yet firm stance on retail fraud cases, Judge McCabe considers both the nature of the offense and the character of the defendant.

Here’s what could impact the outcome of your case:

1. Your Criminal History: As a first-time offender, you might be eligible for alternatives to jail time, such as probation or diversion programs.
2. Restitution and Remorse: Expressing genuine remorse and willingness to pay restitution can make a positive impression.
3. Legal Representation: A knowledgeable attorney can help present your case effectively, highlighting your clean record and the circumstances that led to the incident.

Why Good People Make Bad Decisions: The Psychology of Retail Fraud
Retail fraud is rarely about greed or criminal intent, especially for first-time offenders. In many cases, it’s a momentary lapse in judgment fueled by stress, financial pressure, or emotional distress.

Key Psychological Factors:

• Impulse Control Issues: Stress and anxiety can impair decision-making, leading to impulsive actions.
• Financial Strain: For some, shoplifting feels like the only way to cope with financial hardship.
• Opportunity and Risk Perception: Large stores with limited security can create a sense of low risk, making the decision seem less severe.

By understanding the underlying reasons for your actions, you and your attorney can build a defense that addresses these factors with empathy and clarity.

Common Myths About Retail Fraud Charges

Myth 1: You Must Leave the Store to Be Charged with Shoplifting
Fact: In Michigan, simply moving merchandise with the intent to steal can lead to charges, even if you haven’t left the store.

Myth 2: Retail Fraud Is a Minor Offense
Fact: While often viewed as petty, a retail fraud conviction can carry severe penalties, including jail time, fines, and a permanent criminal record.

Myth 3: Paying for the Item Later Will Dismiss Charges
Fact: Offering to pay for stolen merchandise after being caught does not negate the offense or prevent charges.

Defense Strategies for Retail Fraud in Fenton
A strong defense is essential for minimizing the impact of a retail fraud charge. Here are some strategies your attorney might consider:

1. Lack of Intent: Proving that you did not intend to permanently take the items can be a powerful defense.
2. Diversion Programs: First-time offenders might qualify for programs that result in charges being dismissed upon successful completion.
3. Plea Bargains: In some cases, negotiating a lesser charge or alternative sentencing can help you avoid a criminal record.

Diversion Programs and HYTA Eligibility

For first-time offenders, diversion programs offer a path to keep retail fraud charges off your record. Under Michigan’s Holmes Youthful Trainee Act (HYTA), offenders under 26 may also avoid a criminal record upon completing probation successfully.

How an Attorney Can Help You Move Forward
Having an attorney who understands Michigan’s retail fraud laws and has experience in Judge McCabe’s courtroom can make a significant difference. Here’s how:

1. Personalized Defense Strategy: Tailoring a defense based on your situation, background, and the specifics of the charge.
2. Courtroom Representation: Presenting your case effectively to Judge McCabe, emphasizing your clean record and willingness to make amends.
3. Empathy and Support: Providing guidance and emotional support throughout a stressful process.

Turning a Mistake into an Opportunity for Growth

While a retail fraud charge is serious, it can also serve as a wake-up call—a chance to reflect, learn, and make better decisions in the future. By understanding the factors that led to this mistake and working proactively to address them, you can turn this challenge into an opportunity for growth.
​
If you’re facing retail fraud charges in Fenton, contacting an experienced attorney should be your first step. A professional who understands the local court system and has a track record of helping first-time offenders can guide you toward the best possible outcome.